← back to the index
OW-010 Yacht race · Bass Strait 1998

The 1998 Sydney–Hobart Race — A Boxing Day classic torn apart in Bass Strait

stormpartial-loss1950-1999
Lost
6 sailors of ~1,135
Voyage
Sydney–Hobart offshore race
Ended
Storm in Bass Strait, 27–28 Dec 1998
Status
Partial loss

Summary

On 27–28 December 1998 a violent storm struck the fleet of the Sydney to Hobart Yacht Race in Bass Strait, the notoriously shallow and turbulent water between mainland Australia and Tasmania, killing six sailors and sinking five boats in the deadliest edition of the race's history. Of the 115 yachts that started the 628-nautical-mile course from Sydney Harbour to Hobart on Boxing Day, only 44 finished. Seven yachts were abandoned, five of them sank, and 55 sailors were lifted to safety in what became the largest peacetime rescue operation Australia had mounted, involving some 35 aircraft and 27 Royal Australian Navy vessels.

The storm was an intense, fast-forming low — an East Coast Low that deepened explosively over Bass Strait — bringing sustained winds above 65 knots, gusts toward 80, and seas reported to 15 metres. The shallow Strait stacked the swell into steep, breaking walls that rolled and dismasted boats across the fleet. Glyn Charles was swept overboard from Sword of Orion and never recovered. Aboard Business Post Naiad, Bruce Guy died of a heart attack and Phil Skeggs drowned during repeated knockdowns. The 1942-built wooden yacht Winston Churchill broke up and sank, and three of her crew — John Dean, James Lawler and Michael Bannister — died after their life raft was overwhelmed in the seas.

The race is remembered as the disaster that ended an era of assumed invulnerability in one of yachting's premier events. A New South Wales coronial inquest, its findings released on 12 December 2000, was sharply critical of both the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia, which it found had "abdicated its responsibility to manage the race," and the Bureau of Meteorology for failing to ensure that the deteriorating forecast reached the fleet with the force it warranted. The inquest's recommendations reshaped the race and influenced offshore safety worldwide.

Timeline

26 Dec 1998
Boxing Day start
115 yachts set off from Sydney Harbour on the 628-nautical-mile race to Hobart in fine conditions before a watching crowd.
26–27 Dec 1998
A low deepens
An East Coast Low formed and intensified rapidly over the Tasman and Bass Strait, far stronger than the fleet had anticipated.
27 Dec 1998, daytime
The storm hits Bass Strait
Winds rose above 65 knots with gusts toward 80; seas built to a reported 15 metres in the shallow Strait.
27 Dec 1998
Sword of Orion
The yacht was rolled and dismasted; Glyn Charles was swept overboard and, despite a search, never found.
27 Dec 1998
Business Post Naiad
Repeatedly knocked down and rolled, the boat lost crewmen Bruce Guy to a heart attack and Phil Skeggs to drowning.
27 Dec 1998
Winston Churchill founders
The 1942 wooden yacht was holed and broke up; her nine crew took to two life rafts as she sank.
27–28 Dec 1998
The rafts overwhelmed
Three Winston Churchill crew — John Dean, James Lawler and Michael Bannister — died when their raft was repeatedly capsized in the seas.
27–28 Dec 1998
Mass rescue
Some 35 military and civilian aircraft and 27 Royal Australian Navy vessels mounted Australia's largest peacetime rescue, lifting 55 sailors to safety.
28 Dec 1998
The toll settles
Six sailors were dead, five boats had sunk and seven were abandoned; most of the fleet had retired.
Dec 1998 / Jan 1999
Sayonara finishes
Larry Ellison's maxi Sayonara took line honours, the result overshadowed by the deaths behind the fleet.
12 Dec 2000
Coronial findings
NSW Coroner John Abernethy released his inquest report, criticizing the race organizers and the Bureau of Meteorology and recommending sweeping safety changes.

The classic, and the water it crosses

The Sydney to Hobart, run each Boxing Day since 1945, is among the most prestigious and demanding offshore races in the world: 628 nautical miles south from Sydney Harbour, down the New South Wales coast, across Bass Strait and into the Derwent at Hobart. Its reputation rests on Bass Strait, the body of water that separates the Australian mainland from Tasmania — shallow, exposed to the full fetch of the Southern Ocean, and capable of turning a swell into steep, breaking seas far more dangerous than their open-ocean equivalent. The 1998 race drew 115 yachts, from professionally crewed maxis to smaller boats sailed by capable amateurs, and started in fine summer weather before the usual crowds.

The fleet sailed into a developing East Coast Low, a weather system endemic to the region but, on this occasion, deepening with unusual speed and intensity directly across the race's path. As with so many offshore disasters, the crews set out understanding that hard weather was likely, but the storm that materialized exceeded what the forecasts had led the fleet to expect, and it arrived where the water was at its most treacherous. By the afternoon of 27 December, the front of the fleet was committed to Bass Strait with no practical shelter as the wind rose past survival conditions for many of the boats.

A storm in the Strait

The low brought sustained winds above 65 knots and gusts toward 80, and over the shallow Strait it raised seas reported to 15 metres — short, vertical and breaking, the most dangerous form a sea can take. Boats that could have ridden out comparable winds in deep water were instead picked up and thrown by waves that broke over them. Knockdowns and full rolls swept the fleet; masts came down, rudders sheared, hatches and windows stove in, and crews were flung about cabins and cockpits. The deaths, when they came, were not from a single catastrophe but from the specific ways the sea found each boat.

Sword of Orion was rolled and dismasted, and Glyn Charles, a British Olympic sailor, was swept from the cockpit; though clipped on, he was lost when his harness gave, and a search in the conditions could not recover him. Business Post Naiad was rolled repeatedly: Bruce Guy suffered a fatal heart attack during the ordeal, and Phil Skeggs drowned, trapped, in one of the knockdowns. The Winston Churchill, a beloved 1942 wooden yacht and a veteran of the race, was holed by a wave and broke up; her nine crew abandoned into two life rafts as she sank. In the rafts, repeatedly capsized and battered through the night, three men — John Dean, James Lawler and Michael Bannister — were lost, while the others endured until rescue.

The rescue and the reckoning

The response was immense. Some 35 military and civilian aircraft and 27 Royal Australian Navy vessels combed thousands of square miles of Bass Strait in Australia's largest peacetime rescue operation, with helicopter crews winching sailors from pitching decks and from life rafts in seas that pushed aircraft and rescuers to their limits. Fifty-five sailors were brought to safety, many in dramatic single rescues that became the enduring images of the disaster. The seamanship and courage of the rescue crews almost certainly held the death toll where it stopped.

Even so, six men died, five yachts sank, seven were abandoned, and only 44 of the 115 starters reached Hobart. Sayonara, Larry Ellison's maxi, took line honours, but the result was beside the point. The disaster prompted a New South Wales coronial inquest that probed the conduct of the race and the warnings that preceded it. Released on 12 December 2000, Coroner John Abernethy's findings were unsparing: the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia, the organizer, had "abdicated its responsibility to manage the race," its officials acting, he said, as observers rather than managers, and the Bureau of Meteorology had not done enough to drive home to the fleet how severe the forecast had become. The inquest issued a long list of safety recommendations.

The Five Factors

01
A storm worse than the forecast, in the worst water
The East Coast Low deepened faster and harder than the fleet expected and struck in Bass Strait, where shallow water turns wind into breaking seas. The crews planned for the forecast and met something beyond it. When a system can intensify rapidly over dangerous ground, the warnings must convey the worst credible case, not the expected one.
02
Organizers who watched rather than managed
The inquest found the race organizers had effectively delegated the safety decision to individual skippers, declining to actively manage the fleet as the weather turned. An event that puts a large fleet to sea retains responsibility for it; abdicating that role at the decisive moment leaves each boat to discover the danger alone, too late.
03
A warning that did not land with force
The Bureau of Meteorology's deteriorating forecast did not reach the fleet with the urgency the conditions demanded. Information that exists but is not driven home is functionally absent. The reform — requiring maximum gust and wave-height figures in forecasts — was an attempt to make the severity unmissable.
04
Breaking seas that overwhelm sound boats
Fifteen-metre breaking waves rolled, dismasted and holed boats that would have survived the wind alone, including the destruction of a sturdy older yacht and the capsizing of life rafts. The mechanism is the steep, shoaling sea, not merely the gale. Recognizing that certain waters magnify a storm beyond a vessel's design limits is essential to deciding whether to be there at all.
05
The rafts as a fatal last resort
Aboard Winston Churchill, the crew abandoned a sinking hull into life rafts that were then capsized repeatedly, and three men died in them. As at Fastnet two decades earlier, the supposed refuge proved lethal in extreme seas. The recurring lesson is that rafts are a final option, survivable only narrowly, and that everything possible should keep the crew with a floating boat first.

Aftermath

Six sailors died — Glyn Charles, Bruce Guy, Phil Skeggs, John Dean, James Lawler and Michael Bannister — and the 1998 race remains the deadliest in the event's history. The coronial inquest's recommendations, together with reviews by Australian yachting authorities, drove substantial change: stricter qualification and experience requirements for boats and crews, mandatory safety equipment and training, improved communications and position reporting, and forecasting reforms requiring explicit maximum wind-gust and wave-height information. The criticism of the organizers reset the duty of care owed by race management to a fleet at sea, a principle that carried into offshore events internationally.

The disaster is remembered with gravity in Australian sailing and beyond. It demonstrated, like the Fastnet of 1979 before it, that a premier race in capable hands can still be undone when an underestimated storm meets dangerous water, and that the institutions running such events bear real responsibility for the lives they commit to the sea. The rescue crews who saved 55 people in Bass Strait are honored alongside the men who did not come home — a balance the record keeps deliberately, neither romanticizing the race nor erasing the cost of it.

Lessons

  1. When a storm can deepen fast over dangerous water, warnings must convey the worst credible case, not the expected one.
  2. An organization that puts a fleet to sea owns the duty to manage it; do not delegate the safety call to individuals once conditions turn.
  3. A forecast that is not driven home with force is functionally absent; make severity unmissable, in concrete numbers.
  4. Treat shoaling, breaking seas as a multiplier that can exceed a boat's limits regardless of skill — and weigh whether to be in that water at all.
  5. Keep the crew with a floating boat as long as possible; a life raft in extreme seas is a narrow, last-ditch refuge, not a rescue.

References