On 20 November 1820 the Nantucket whaleship Essex, under first-time captain George Pollard Jr., was rammed twice and sunk by a large sperm whale in the remote equatorial Pacific, roughly 2,000 nautical miles west of South America. The crew of twenty escaped into three small whaleboats with a meager salvage of bread and fresh water. Twelve of them would not survive. After about three months adrift, only eight men lived to be rescued; some endured by eating the bodies of shipmates who had died, and in one boat by killing a chosen man after the survivors drew lots.
The disaster turned on a single navigational decision. The Marquesas and Society Islands lay downwind, within reach. Pollard wished to run for them, but his officers, Owen Chase chief among them, feared the islanders were cannibals and argued instead for the far longer beat toward the coast of Chile and Peru, against wind and current. Pollard yielded. The choice condemned the men to a voyage of more than 2,500 nautical miles in open boats, and to the very starvation and cannibalism they had sailed to avoid. The islands they feared were, in fact, safe; traders had been calling at them without harm.
The Essex is remembered less for the whale than for what followed it: a clinical demonstration of how fear of the unknown can be deadlier than the unknown itself, and how command under starvation collapses into the drawing of lots. First mate Owen Chase published his Narrative in 1821; cabin boy Thomas Nickerson wrote his own account decades later. Together they reached a young Herman Melville, who built the ending of Moby-Dick upon a whale that turns on the ship that hunts it.
On 2 July 1816 the French Navy frigate Méduse, bound for Senegal under Viscount Hugues Duroy de Chaumareys, ran aground on the Bank of Arguin off the coast of present-day Mauritania, the result of incompetent navigation that had carried the ship some 160 kilometres off course. The frigate carried roughly 400 people; her six boats could take only about 250. When efforts to refloat the hull failed, the senior officers and officials took to the boats, and at least 146 men and one woman were crowded onto a hastily built raft about 20 metres long, intended to be towed ashore.
Within a few miles the tow lines were cast off — by accident or by choice the record disputes — and the raft was abandoned on the open sea, almost awash, with little food and a quantity of wine but scarcely any fresh water. Over the next thirteen days the people on it died by the score: drowned, killed in fighting on the first nights, starved, driven to suicide, and in the end eaten by the survivors. When the brig Argus sighted the raft on 17 July, fifteen men were still alive; several died soon after rescue. The boats had reached the Senegalese coast; almost everyone left on the raft had not.
The Méduse is remembered less as a shipwreck than as an indictment. The grounding was avoidable, the abandonment of the raft was a betrayal, and the appointment of a captain who had barely sailed in twenty years was a symptom of a navy handing command by royalist favour rather than competence. Two survivors, the surgeon Henri Savigny and the engineer Alexandre Corréard, published an account that became an international scandal, and the young painter Théodore Géricault built from it Le Radeau de la Méduse, fixing the disaster permanently in the public conscience.
The yacht Mignonette, a small cruising boat being delivered from England to a buyer in Australia, foundered in a gale in the South Atlantic on 5 July 1884, roughly 1,600 nautical miles northwest of the Cape of Good Hope. Her four-man crew — captain Tom Dudley, mate Edwin Stephens, the sailor Edmund Brooks, and the seventeen-year-old cabin boy Richard Parker — escaped into a thirteen-foot lifeboat with almost no provisions: two tins of turnips and no fresh water. They caught a turtle a few days later, but by the third week they were starving and drinking their own urine, and Parker, who had also drunk seawater, lay dying in the bottom of the boat.
On 25 July, after about twenty days adrift and with no sail in sight, Dudley, with the assent of Stephens, cut the boy’s throat with a penknife. The three men drank his blood and ate his body to survive. Brooks took no part in the killing but shared the food. Four days later, on 29 July, the German barque Montezuma sighted the boat and rescued the three living men. They made no secret of what they had done, believing it sanctioned by the seafarers’ grim “custom of the sea” — that starving castaways might draw lots and sacrifice one to save the rest.
The law disagreed. Dudley and Stephens were tried at Exeter and, in the judgment of R v Dudley and Stephens (1884), convicted of murder, the court ruling that necessity is no defence to the deliberate killing of an innocent person. Sentenced to death, they were reprieved by the Crown to six months’ imprisonment. The case did not turn on whether the men were monstrous — the court accepted their suffering — but on whether desperation can license one person to kill another. It remains a cornerstone of the common law on murder and necessity.
On the night of 13–14 May 1866 the three-masted ship General Grant, bound from Melbourne to London under Captain William Loughlin, drifted in light winds onto the towering western cliffs of the main Auckland Island, in the subantarctic ocean some 460 kilometres south of New Zealand. The ship was carried into a great sea cave; her mainmast struck the rock roof and was driven down through the hull, and she filled and sank in the cave with most of the 83 people aboard still trapped inside. Sixty-eight drowned. Only fifteen reached the shore of one of the loneliest archipelagos on earth, and of those, ten would live to be rescued eighteen months later.
The survivors landed with almost nothing and faced a climate of near-constant rain, wind and cold. Their lives turned on fire and food. They learned to keep a fire burning continuously, having no reliable means to relight it, and they lived on seals, sea birds and their eggs, wild pigs descended from animals left by earlier visitors, and roots, eventually moving to better ground on Enderby Island. The Auckland Islands lay far off any shipping route, so no rescue could be expected to come looking; the castaways’ only hope was endurance or their own escape. After nine months, four of the strongest men set out in a small boat to reach New Zealand without compass or chart. They were never seen again.
The General Grant is remembered as one of the great subantarctic castaway ordeals, and as a lesson in the lethal isolation of the southern islands. One more survivor, David McLelland, died of illness on the island before the end. The remaining ten were found in November 1867 by the brig Amherst, by chance rather than by search, after eighteen months of marooned survival. The wreck — and a cargo that reportedly included gold — has drawn salvage expeditions ever since, but the ship has never been certainly relocated within the cave, and the bones of those who drowned lie there still.
The Mary Celeste, an American brigantine of about 282 tons, was found adrift and deserted in the North Atlantic on 4 December 1872, roughly 400 nautical miles east of the Azores, by the Canadian brigantine Dei Gratia. She was seaworthy and still under partial sail, her cargo of 1,701 barrels of denatured alcohol nearly intact, six months of provisions aboard, and the personal effects of those who had sailed in her undisturbed. Her single lifeboat was gone, along with the ship’s chronometer, sextant and papers. No one aboard was ever seen again. Captain Benjamin Spooner Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia, and the seven crewmen had vanished — ten people in all — and the reason has never been established.
The ship had cleared New York on 7 November 1872, bound for Genoa. Her last log entry was dated 25 November, placing her near Santa Maria in the Azores. The boarding party from the Dei Gratia found about three and a half feet of water in the hold, a sounding rod left on deck, and a single pump disassembled. The disorder was consistent not with violence but with a hurried, deliberate abandonment: the people had left the ship by their own hand, into a small boat, and the sea had taken them. The vessel they fled then floated on without them for nine or ten days until another ship found her.
What makes the Mary Celeste notorious is less the event than the fiction grown over it. There was no warm meal left on the table, no fire still burning in the galley, no sign of struggle, no abandoned breakfast — those are inventions, most influentially Arthur Conan Doyle’s 1884 short story, which even renamed the ship “Marie Celeste.” Stripped of embellishment, the documented case points to a frightened, rational evacuation that went fatally wrong: a captain who believed his ship was sinking or about to explode, ordered everyone into a boat that could not survive the open Atlantic, and lost them all.